Managing Holiday Credit Card Debt

Imagine yourself at a department store. You are approaching the check out. How are you going to pay for this purchase? Are you using your debit card because you planned your holiday spending? Or are you using your credit cards because your only plan is to spend and eventually pay it back?

When it comes down to holiday spending, we have a choice.

Choice #1: We can go into the holidays financially blind and spend to our heart’s content and put our heads in the sand and deal with it in the New Year. This is the way a lot of people approach the holidays and they pay for it monetarily and emotionally. Not only that, but their credit scores take a hit as their credit card balances rise. Their monthly costs go up because the minimum payments on their cards increase due to larger balances. This reduces their spending power until they pay off some of that holiday debt!

Choice #2: Go into the holidays with a spending plan that let’s you buy thoughtful gifts for your family and friends but does not allow you to break the bank. That is really the best course of action. A plan is always better than winging it and winging it with money is never a good idea. To make this action effective, you have to save before the holidays come. Set up an automatic transfer from your checking to a savings account.

Next year in January, you may want to open a “Christmas or Holiday Club” account for your holiday savings if your bank or credit union still offers that. The old club accounts had money automatically transferred from your checking account and was cashed in before the holidays and paid out to the accountholder to pay for gifts. Lacking a “Christmas Club” type of account? Open a savings especially for your holiday spending and set up an automatic transfer from your checking account each month. The automatic transfer happens without any action on your part. Just remember to enter it in your check register or monitor your online banking so you don’t overdraw your checking. When the holidays are here, draw the funds from your savings and spend it to your heart’s content.

If you must use credit to pay for your gift giving, let’s consider some things that might save us some money. Let’s assume you plan to pay this newly incurred balance off in six months. How much do you plan to spend on gifts? That’s the starting point. Take that amount and divide it by six and add that to your current monthly payment on that card. Can you afford that payment monthly for the next six months? Then you may have the right amount to spend on gifts. Is it too high? You need to adjust your spending plan, not your time horizon for pay off! Remember, extending the pay off time for any balance adds more interest to your debt. Paying interest is like renting money. Who benefits when you pay interest? Certainly not me or you. The bank does! If this sounds like a good idea, you use way too much credit and need an intervention!

But, if you really like making that monthly payment and the cost is no object for you, then you might be more inclined to take Choice #1.

*           *           *

Our next financial education workshop will be “Real World Budgets for Teens” and will be presented at our Chesbro Main Office on January 16^th at 6:30pm. Real World Budgets takes a teen and their parents thru a post college simulation of managing money, a job, and the payments that come with independence. I hope you can join us.

Please RSVP with Greg Meyer at gmeyer@meriwest.com or 408-365-6328.

Click here for a list of all of our financial education offerings.

Check us out on Facebook! WWW.Facebook.com/MeriwestCreditUnion

Does Good Debt Exist?

Good debt does still exist. Home debt, if you are not dramatically underwater is still good debt. Please remember that the majority of home owners have seen some degradation of their equity, but most homeowners are not underwater. The generally accepted number is somewhere between 20-25% of all homeowners have a home that is underwater. Most of these were either purchased or refinanced during the recent boom in prices, especially 2005 to 2008. It is a simple truth that 75% or more of all U.S. homeowners are not underwater. Homes purchased today with a reasonable downpayment of 20% or more may have some stagnant price growth in the near term, but historically, owning a home is a sure path to wealth creation. When you consider the tax advantages of owning a home and the increase in value even if it only follows regular inflation rates, new homeowners will incur good debt.

Is college debt good debt? Many are of the opinion that education is important and the resulting debt from financing it is still a good debt. That is provided the student finishes and graduates. Statistics show that lifetime earnings of those with bachelors and masters degrees are substantially higher than those with only a high school education. I have many former college students in my workshops who have not graduated and have substantial student loan debts. Those debts become good debt and will be well worth it when they finish their degrees.

Is all credit card debt bad debt? Not necessarily. Often, young persons will use a credit card like it is going out of style. They will pay for movies, dinners out, concerts, and other fun items with their credit cards. That is some bad debt; debt where you have little or nothing but memories to show for it. I think the responsible use of credit cards is in purchasing assets for your home or car. Use the card for furniture, needed appliances or a major car repair. That way, when you are on your couch writing a check for your Visa card payment, you are sitting on your asset. (A little finance humor.)

Vehicle debt can often be termed good debt. Your car is an economic development vehicle. It gets you to work on time and gets your kids to school. Is spending 2 hours plus on a bus or train daily the best use of your personal time? It is a matter of opportunity cost. How much is your personal time worth?

In the end, I think that the difference between good debt and bad debt is subjective. Our income, education, and cultural background all play a role in how we view the value, really the personal value, of our debt. 

*   *   *

Our next financial workshop:

Today's Real Estate Market and Tips for Purchasing Foreclosed Property
Saturday, October 13, 2012 - 10:30 a.m.
Chesbro Financial Center, San Jose, CA

The Costs of Bad Credit Part 2

The cost of bad credit can be very high; provided a credit issuer will give you credit. Last week, we looked at the costs of incurring bad credit such as late fees and higher rates. This week we will take a look at who may lend to a risky borrower and the extended cost of bad credit.

A credit score indicates to the lender the likelihood of a loan being repaid. The higher the FICO score, the more likely a loan will be repaid. Often times, those with low scores are offered a higher (AKA sub-prime) rate for car, home, and other credit purchases. It would not be unusual for someone with a low rating to be offered a 10-14% or higher interest rate on a used car loan when the prevailing rates for someone with a good credit rating would be about 7% or less. That was prior to the recent recession. Lenders are much more conscious of the defaults in subprime loans that have occurred over the past 5 years. Many have stepped away from the subprime market completely. Thus, for many lenders, either you qualify for a loan or you don’t. The subprime loan is no longer an option for many traditional lenders or many borrowers.

There are still some institutions that will lend to people with slightly less than perfect credit; they are known as credit unions. Why? Because credit unions take a more holistic approach to lending to their members. The FICO Score is important, but is not the only factor considered when lending. A credit union may require a higher down payment of subprime borrowers and/or ask them to pay a slightly higher interest rate. They will look at the applicant’s employment; how long have they worked for the same company? How long have they lived in the same home or neighborhood? How has the member managed their credit over the past 24 months? The answers to these questions may increase or decrease the interest rate or down payment.

As an example, let’s say a FICO score of equal to or greater than 740 is the target score for the institution and someone in that score range will get a rate of 2.99% for a new car loan with zero down. In this case, if someone misses the target by a bit, say the member comes in at 680, the credit union would likely make the loan with a somewhat higher rate than the base rate to help the member. Instead of 2.99%, perhaps the loan would be for 5.50%.

In this case, a car loan of $15,000 applied for a borrower with a 740 score and a borrower with a 680 score, there is a 2.51% difference in the loan rate (2.99% APR vs. 5.50% APR). The borrower with the 740 score will pay only $934 in interest over a 4 year period where the borrower with the lower score might pay as much as $1,745; a difference of $811 over the four year loan term. The borrower may not only be required to pay a higher interest rate, they may have to come up with money for an additional down payment. Subprime borrowers are often called upon to have a higher equity in their security than those with preferred rates. That is an additional cost to the subprime borrower. That is money that has to come out of savings leaving the borrower with reduced liquidity. Another cost is the loss of earned interest on the money used for the down payment. Let’s say the borrower has to put up an additional $3,000 in order to qualify for the loan, $3,000 in a savings account at 1% APY for 4 years would have earned $125. That’s better than spending an additional $800 in interest expenses.

Avoid these increased costs by managing your credit correctly.

• Pay your bills on time and pay more than the minimum when possible.
• Pay down outstanding balances.
• Avoid using your entire credit available limit
• Only apply for credit when you want it. Don’t apply for a card just to get a discount!
• Read your credit contracts. Don’t get caught in a consumer trap. 

*     *     *

Are you planning on buying a home? This is one of the great times to purchase one. Loan rates are low and home prices are starting to rise!  If you are ready to buy, visit our next Homebuyer's Seminar here at the Meriwest Credit Union main office on Sept. 8th. Get all the details you need to finance your home purchase! 

Curious about rates? Here are some links to our current interest rates on consumer and home loans:

Auto Loans - New and Used

Home Loans

Equity Lines of Credit

7 Tips for New Credit Users

1. When establishing your first credit, consider using a secured credit card; a card where you have to make a deposit in a savings account in order to establish and maintain the card. The money on deposit is your security for the credit. You now have an additional incentive to be on time with your payments; your own money is at stake. Meriwest Credit Union offers this type of Secured Visa Card. Info on Secured Visa Cards is here.

2. Another secured type of credit option is the credit union share account loan. Most credit unions have this. You make a deposit to an account and then take a loan out against the funds in the account. As you pay it back on time, your CU lets the credit bureau know and it helps get you get established in managing credit. Secured Share Account Loan info is available here.

3. When you get your first credit card, do not celebrate. There are those who like to go out and get a quick pizza or a movie when their new credit card arrives. A new credit card is not a good excuse to go out to spend and celebrate.

4. Use your credit wisely, purchase assets you need. There are too many people in the world who have credit card bills and have nothing to show for thousands of dollars in debt. Pizzas, concerts, and movies are fleeting and soon forgotten. Furniture is a good reason to use the card. That way, when you are on your couch writing the check for your credit card payment, you have something to show for it. You are sitting on your asset. (Hey, that’s a little credit joke!)

5. Avoid gas cards issued by Shell, Chevron, and other oil companies. Those who are new to credit are often unaware that gas purchases on oil company cards have to be repaid monthly. Only repairs and major purchases, (tires, transmissions, etc.) can be paid over time.

6. Check your credit report annually at AnnualCreditReport.com to verify your current outstanding credit and prevent identity theft. Do you see a card on your report you didn’t order or apply for? If you are reviewing your report annually, you can take action fast and stop identity theft.

7. It seems simplistic, have a budget and plan your spending. A good budget can keep you from using your credit cards or help you pay off the debt you already have.

We are starting to set our schedule of Fall Financial Workshops. If your business, school, or organization has a need for this sort of financial education for employees, students, or clients, please feel free to call upon me to arrange workshops for them. It’s what we do to make our community a better place. 

Please contact Greg Meyer, the Credit Union Guy, at gmeyer@meriwest.com or 408-365-6328 if you are interested.